When Do Landlords Actually Need a Signed W-9 and Form 1099-NEC from a Contractor?
Every January, thousands of landlords scramble to track down contractors they paid months ago—wondering who needs a 1099-NEC and who doesn't. The good news: not every contractor requires a W-9 or 1099-NEC. Everything comes down to three simple questions.
How Did You Pay Them?
If you paid by Credit Card, Debit Card, Stripe, or PayPal/Venmo Business, you do NOT need to file a 1099-NEC. The card processor reports the payment on Form 1099-K. If you paid by Check, ACH, Cash, or Zelle, the reporting responsibility stays with you.
Was It $600+ in the Year?
If your total payments to that contractor across the calendar year are under $600, no 1099-NEC is required—simply save the itemized invoice for your Schedule E tax deductions. Once cumulative payments hit $600 or more, reporting rules apply.
What Is Their Tax Structure?
Sole proprietors, handymen, single-member LLCs, and partnerships require a 1099-NEC. S-Corporations and C-Corporations are generally exempt—but collecting a W-9 is the only way to prove whether an "LLC" is taxed as a sole proprietor or an S-Corp.
| Landlord Payment Scenario | Collect W-9? | File 1099-NEC? | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paid by Credit Card, Debit Card, or PayPal Goods & Services | No | No | Card networks issue Form 1099-K automatically (IRS Sec. 6050W). Sending a 1099-NEC double-reports their income. |
| Paid under $600 total for the calendar year (e.g., $220 lock repair) | No* | No | Below the $600 annual threshold (*unless a second job later in the year pushes their total over $600). |
| Paid $600+ by Check, ACH, Cash, or Zelle to a Handyman / Sole Prop / LLC | Yes | Yes | Zelle does not issue 1099-Ks. Collect the signed W-9 before releasing the final check. |
| Paid $600+ by Check, ACH, or Zelle to an S-Corp or C-Corp | Yes (Once) | No | Corporations are exempt from 1099-NEC, and their signed W-9 on file is your audit-proof record of that exemption. |
| Bought Materials Only (e.g., Home Depot, Lowe's, supply house) | No | No | Purchases of physical goods/materials alone do not require a 1099-NEC. |